Can trading be taught? In 1983, two traders ran an experiment to find out. Newspaper ads, a group of complete novices and about two weeks of training. In this article we look at what Richard Dennis and William Eckhardt set out to prove, what the trainees did next, and the lesson for anyone learning to trade gold today.
The experiment
Richard Dennis believed trading could be taught as a set of rules. His partner William Eckhardt disagreed, arguing that successful traders had something that could not be transferred. To settle it, they recruited 23 trainees through newspaper ads in 1983 and 1984 and trained them for about two weeks. The group became known as the Turtles.
The trainees were not finance professionals. They came from a range of backgrounds and were chosen through the ads rather than through industry connections. That was the point. If people with no trading history could follow a rulebook and succeed, it would show that the rules, not some innate gift, were doing the work.
The lesson: rules beat gut feeling
Many of the trainees went on to trade successfully by following the rules with discipline. A clear rulebook, applied every time, beat gut feeling. The rules told them when to enter, when to exit and how much to risk, and the ones who stuck to them did well. The ones who second-guessed the system tended not to.
For a gold trader, the message is direct. Every trade idea we send comes with an entry, a stop-loss and a take-profit. Those three numbers are a rulebook for that trade. Following them consistently, rather than improvising when the chart looks scary or exciting, is what the Turtle experiment showed to be the real skill. Learn the rules with us in the free community.
Key takeaways
- Dennis believed trading could be taught as rules; Eckhardt disagreed.
- 23 trainees recruited by newspaper ad in 1983 and 1984, trained about two weeks.
- A clear rulebook applied with discipline beat gut feeling.
Common questions
Who were the Turtle Traders?
A group of 23 trainees recruited through newspaper ads in 1983 and 1984 by Richard Dennis and William Eckhardt to test whether trading could be taught as rules.
What did the Turtle Traders experiment prove?
That people with no trading background could succeed by following a clear set of rules with discipline. Consistency mattered more than instinct.
Trade ideas with the levels already worked out
Join the free community and receive XAU/USD trade ideas with entry, stop-loss and take-profit, live training on Tuesdays and Thursdays, and support whenever you are stuck.
Join free on TelegramOpen the calculatorsThe traders featured are not affiliated with, and do not endorse, Gold Trade Signals. Their results are exceptional, not typical.
Risk warning: This article is educational content, not personal investment advice. Gold is a leveraged, volatile instrument and you can lose some or all of your capital. Gold Trade Signals is not FCA regulated. Read the full risk warning.
More from Trader Stories and Habits
Jesse Livermore made and lost fortunes: the risk control lesson
Jesse Livermore profited from the 1907 panic and the 1929 crash, yet went bankrupt around three times. Why his story is a warning about risk control.
Stanley Druckenmiller: from bank trainee to capital preservation
Stanley Druckenmiller left a PhD to become a bank trainee and later worked with George Soros. His core principle, preservation of capital, explained.
Mark Minervini: no finance degree, champion trader, one rule
Mark Minervini left school early, taught himself to trade and won the 1997 US Investing Championship. His edge: cut losses small, never add to a loser.